Old John Brown’s body lies moldering in the grave,
While weep the sons of bondage whom he ventured all to save;
But tho he lost his life while struggling for the slave,
His soul is marching on.
This is an analysis of the Michael Curtiz film Santa Fe Trail that might resemble the analysis of John Ford’s Young Mr Lincoln, a paradigmatic object of cinematic critical analysis.
Young Mr. Lincoln (YML) and ideological analysis: a reconsideration (with many asides) by Chuck Kleinhans Jump Cut: A Review of Contemporary Media (Jump Cut, No. 55, fall 2013)
In 1970 the editors of Cahiers du cinéma published “Young Mr. Lincoln, texte collectif,” an article written by all the editors, which, upon translation into English in Screen (UK) as “John Ford’s Young Mr. Lincoln,” in 1972, became a landmark essay in Anglo-American film theory. The essay was quickly referenced, commented on, and republished repeatedly in film theory anthologies. The commentaries produced a cottage industry of new studies of the 1939 film.
My concern here is to mark the place of the original essay and its subsequent discussion. It needs some context for a new generation, some 40 years later.
Because the French article became so central to key issues in emerging film studies, today’s reader finds many paths leading through and out of the essay, many tangents that turn out to be useful for grasping the essay in the abstract and in history. And it also lets us think about the historical vicissitudes of film theorizing. Reconsideration today also aptly opens further thought in terms of Spielberg’s Lincoln and the larger project of ideological analysis.
In summary, Cahiers argues that the film’s “ideological project” (validating a Lincoln myth to serve an electoral aim) is contradicted in at least five ways:
- There are significant distortions such as deception by shot and editing in the murder scene.
- There are omissions such as scenes that would be needed for the crime thriller genre but which would have lessened the presentation of Lincoln’s omnipotence: for example, he never confronts the accused about what happened, what they know.
- The film relies on exaggerated accentuation as seen in the very heightened drama of the final scenes at the trial and the aftermath.
- There is a scriptural violence, invoking God, and Law, Truth, and Family in a distorted way.
- The film’s project aims at a religious (Puritan) sense of election, that Lincoln’s place is predetermined, but it must maintain suspense and a presentation of free choice in order to maintain basic narrative interest.
So if you haven’t yet dozed off, my project-variation on that magisterial, discipline-defining method for Young Mr. Lincoln (YML) would be to look at the divisions represented by the European war as opposed to the electoral history of YML as a Republican party film, much like today’s White House is a peculiarly odd collection of RW film and television producers.
As a Michael Curtiz film, Santa fe Trail (SFT) has a different directorial perspective than John Ford’s YML. SFT is a more historically positioned text rather than the more mythological YML because it includes secession, slavery, Bloody Kansas, John Brown and Harper’s Ferry. Unlike YML’s God, Law, Truth, and Family, SFT has more to do with religious extremism, insurrection, authority, and the problems of historical revision, especially considering the ideological problems of intersectionality in choosing a revolutionary path. SFT however, is no Django Unchained, but as a historically referential text, it even resembles some contemporary discourses.
Santa Fe Trail (1940) Trailer
The film loosely follows the life of J.E.B. Stuart (Errol Flynn) before the outbreak of the American Civil War. Among its sub-plots include a romance with the fictional Kit Carson Holliday (Olivia de Havilland), friendship with George Armstrong Custer (Ronald Reagan), and battles against abolitionist John Brown (Raymond Massey).
Run time 1:49:26
Production Company Warner Bros. Pictures Inc.
Audio/Visual sound, Black and White
Errol Flynn … Jeb Stuart
Olivia de Havilland … ‘Kit Carson’ Holliday
Raymond Massey … John Brown
Ronald Reagan … George Armstrong Custer
Alan Hale … Tex Bell
William Lundigan … Bob Holliday
Van Heflin … Rader
War in Europe:
On December 20, the day of the New York release of the film Santa Fe Trail, the Roosevelt administration announced the establishment of an Office of Production Management, the goal of which was to expand defense efforts and speed military aid to the British and other non-Axis powers.
On December 21 the German government denounced the act as a form of “moral aggression.”
On December 29, President Roosevelt, in a “Fireside Chat,” (his second of the year—the previous one was in May 1940) called for a huge war production effort that would make the United States “the great arsenal of democracy”: planes, ships, guns, and munitions for those countries fighting for Democracy.
"Abolition is a movement which is intended to change everything…abolitionists of the current era…we started with prison, but not because prison is alone the problem, but rather because it condenses all of the problems that radiate throughout our society.”- Ruth Wilson Gilmore
— Damien Sojoyner (@BrotherSojo) November 25, 2020
Angela Davis reminding us as always that the etymological meaning of "radical" is "root" –– that abolition allows us to get at the root of the problem, and escape from the same framework and footprint of reform.
— micah (@micahherskind) December 2, 2020
Today is the International Day for the Abolition of Slavery. Today let's focus on eradicating contemporary forms of Slavery, trafficking, child labour amongst other things. @WeAreNorthMid @NorthMidNHS pic.twitter.com/i29G0LpAvQ
— Nicole Callender (@NicoleCNHS) December 2, 2020
Today is the International Day for the Abolition of Slavery. As we remember those whose lives were blighted by the sin of the slave trade, let us recommit to ending the evil of modern slavery in all its forms.
— Archbishop of Canterbury (@JustinWelby) December 2, 2020